TYRON MARHGUY V. BOARD OF GOVERNORS ACHIMOTA SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL: A COMMENTARY
Keywords:
ACHIMOTA SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL, GOVERNORS, TYRON MARHGUYAbstract
This comment is a reflection on the 2021 Ghanaian case of Tyron Marhguy v. Board of Governors Achimota Senior High School and Anor (hereafter, Marhguy) and brings to the fore the Ghanaian judicial standpoint on the enforcement of the right to freedom of religion and belief. In the case, the Applicant successfully contested the violation of his fundamental human right to freedom of religion and belief. Jurisprudentially, Marhguy is phenomenal, being a locus classicus setting out the judicial approval to the constitutional protection of religious liberty in Ghana. More importantly, Ghana is a country with constitutional democracy and religious pluralism, and the effect of the case may ultimately shape religion-state relations in the country. Expectedly, given the religiosity of Ghanaians, the court decision elicited much public commentary and debate; but as significant as the case, there has not been much legal and academic discourse on it. The issues that resonated in the case touch on constitutionally guaranteed human rights, including the right to freedom of religion and belief, the right to education, and the right to human dignity. However, the focus of this commentary is limited to the issues concerning the right to freedom of religion. Thus, after a summary of the facts of the case and the decision of the court, this discussion primarily evaluates only the issues
Downloads
References
‘Achimota: You Deny Rastafarians but Admit ‘White’ Students with Hair – Twitter Rants’ (Ghanaweb 23 March 2021) <https://www.ghanaweb.com/GhanaHomePage/NewsArchive/Achimota-You-deny-Rastafarians-but-admit-white-students-with-hair-Twitter-rants-1212883 16 June 2022> accessed 12 November 2022;
‘Rastafarian Students Win Case Against Achimota School-Court Orders Admission’ <https://avenuegh.com/rastafarian-students-win-case-against-achimota-school-court-orders-admission/> accessed 12 November 2022.
Abena Ampofoa Asare, Truth Without Reconciliation: A Human Rights History of Ghana (University of Pennsylvania Press, Philadephia 2018) 1-15.
Alfred L Matambo, ‘Implications of Religious Intolerance on State Security in Africa: A Case Study Lilongwe in Malawi’ (Thesis – University of Nairobi).
Alison Mawhinney, ‘The Opt-out Clause: Imperfect Protection for the Right to Freedom of Religion in Schools’ (2006) Education Law Journal 102;
C Prempeh, ‘Balancing Religious Freedoms and the Right to Education of Minorities in Ghana: A Focus on Access to Public Senior High Schools by Rastafarians’ in M.E. Addadzi-Koom, M. Addaney, L.A. Nkansah (eds) Democratic Governance, Law, and Development in Africa (Palgrave Macmillan, Cham. 2022) 193-222.
C Y Nyinevi and E N Amasah, ‘The Separation of Church and State under Ghana’s Fourth Republic” (2015) 8(4) Journal of Politics and Law 286;
Elom Dovlo, ‘Religion in the Public Sphere: Challenges and Opportunities in Ghanaian Law-making, 1989-2004’ (2005) Brigham Young University Law Review 629;
Evans Effah ‘Wesley Girls’ High School Sued Over Compulsory Religious Practices’ 3 News 24 December 2024, <https://3news.com/news/education/wesley-girls-high-school-sued-over-compulsory-religious-practices/> accessed on 19 January 2025.
Fortune Sibanda, ‘Repositioning the Agency of Rastafari in the Context of Covid-19 Crisis in Zimbabwe’ in F. Sibanda, T Muyambo and E Chitando (eds) Religion and the Covid-19 Pandemic in Southern Africa (Abingdon and New York: Routledge 2022) 213.
H. Van Coller, ‘Church Polity and ‘Constitutionalism’” in LJ Koffeman and J Smith (eds) Protestant Church Polity in Changing Contexts II (2014) Lit Verlag: Zurich.162;
Idowu A Akinloye, ‘Acquisition and Protection of Church Property under Nigerian Law: Issues, Challenges and some Lessons for Churches’ (2021) 47(4) Commonwealth Law Bulletin, 741-761.
I.A. Akinloye, ‘Legal Issues Involving Succession Disputes among South African Churches: Some Lessons’ (2021) 23(2) Ecclesiastical Law Journal (2021) 160-190
Idowu A Akinloye, “The Right to Freedom of Religion or Belief: African Perspectives”, in Ferrari S, Hill M, Jamal AA and Bottoni (eds). Routledge Handbook of Freedom of Religion or Belief (Abingdon and New York: Routledge, 2021) 189.
Ilene Allgood, ‘Faith and Freedom of Religion in U.S. Public Schools: Issues and Challenges Facing Teachers (2016) 111(3) Religious Education 270-287
J.L. Van der Walt, ‘Religious Tolerance and Intolerance: 'Engravings' on the Soul’ (2016) 50(1) In die Skriflig 1-8.
Joseph Yaw Asomah, ‘Cultural Rights Versus Human Rights: A Critical Analysis of the Trokosi Practice in Ghana and the Role of Civil Society’ (2015) 15(1) African Human Rights Law Journal 129.
K Fosnacht and C Broderick, ‘Religious Intolerance on Campus: A Multi-Institution Study’ (2020) Journal of College and Character, 21(4), 244–262.
K Quashigah, ‘Religion and the Republican State in Africa: The Need for a Distanced Relationship’ (2014) 14 African Human Rights Law Journal 78.
K Quashigah, ‘Religion and the Secular State in Ghana’ in J Martinez-Torrón, WC Durham Jr, and D Thayer (eds). Religion and Secular State: National Reports (Madrid: Servicio de Publicaciones de la Facultad de Derecho de la Universidad Complutense de Madrid, 2010) 331, 333:
K Tsuitui and CM Wotipka ‘Global Civil Society and International Human Rights’ (2004) 83 Social Forces 587-620.
Leni Franken, ‘The Freedom of Religion and the Freedom of Education in Twenty-First-Century Belgium: A Critical Approach’ (2016) 38(3) British Journal of Religious Education 308-324.
M.H.A. Bolaji, ‘Secularism and State Neutrality: The 2015 Muslim Protest of Discrimination in the Public Schools in Ghana’ (2018) 48 Journal of Religion in Africa 65-104 at 67.
OV Vieira and AS Dupree, ‘Reflections on Civil Society and Human Rights’ (2004) 1 Sur International Journal of Human Rights 47-65;
R I J Hackett, ‘Regulating Religious Freedom in Africa’ (2011) 25 Emory International Law Review 853.
S Nkrumah-Pobi and S Owusu-Afriyie, ‘Religious Pluralism in Ghana: Using the Accommodative Nature of African Indigenous Religion (AIR) as a Source for Religious Tolerance and Peaceful Coexistence’ (2020) 3(1) International Journal of Interreligious and Intercultural Studies 73-82.
W.C. Iheme, ‘Religious Intolerance, Witchcraft, Superstition, and Underdevelopment in Africa’ (2020) 25(2) Skeptic 22-24.
STATUTES
African [Banjul] Charter on Human and Peoples' Rights, adopted June 27, 1981, OAU Doc. CAB/LEG/67/3 rev. 5, 21 I.L.M. 58 (1982), entered into force Oct. 21, 1986.
Declaration on the Elimination of All Forms of Intolerance and of Discrimination Based on Religion or Belief (General Assembly Resolution 36/55 of November 1981).
CASE LAW
Achene v Raji (Casebook on the Rights of Women in Ghana, 1959-2005) 289
Alhasuna Muslim Faith v. Regional Police Commander, Bolgatanga 1994-2000] CHRAJ 191.
Ariovi v Elemo (1983) JELR 49375 (SC)
Department of Correctional Services & Another v. Police and Prisons Civil Rights and 5 Ors (2013) ZASCA 40.
Dzova v. Minister of Education, Sports and Culture and Ors (2007) AHRLR 189; (ZWSC 2007).
JWM (Alias P) v. Board of Management High School & 2 Ors (2019) EKLR.
Lagos State Govt. and Ors v. Asiyat Abdulkareem (Suit No.: SC 910/2016).
Lagos State Govt. and Ors v. Asiyat Abdulkareem (Suit No.: SC 910/2016).
MEC for Education, KwaZulu-Natal v Pillay 2008 (1) SA 474 (CC).
MEC for Education, KwaZulu-Natal v Pillay para 58. (Civil Appeal No. 173 of 2020).
Phillip Okoth and LSK v BOM, St Anne’s Primary Ahero [2023] (Civil Appeal No. 173 of 2020)
Phillip Okoth and LSK v BOM, St Anne’s Primary Ahero pp. 21, 25-26.
Raphael Cubagee v. Michael Yeboah Asare and 2 Orthers (Ref. No. 16/04/2017)
Seventh Day Adventist Church (East Africa) Limited v Minister for Education & 3 others [2017] KECA 751 (KLR).
The Provost, Kwara State College of Education, Ilorin & 2 Ors vs. Bashirat Saliu & 2 Ors (Appeal No. CA/IL/49/2006).);
The Republic v. Eugene Baffoe-Bonnie and 4 Ors (Ref. No. J1/06/2018).
Tyron Marhguy v. Board of Governors Achimota Senior High School and Anor (Suit No. HR/0055/2021) (2021) JELR 107192 (HC).
